About Buttercup Counseling
Therapy and EMDR for high-achieving adults in Fishers, supporting you as you make space for your needs and create a more joyful, genuine life.
Success?
You’ve got it … on paper.
You’ve hustled for every gold star, played by the rules, and still, something feels hollow.
But inside, there’s a restless voice that never quiets, an ache that tells you there’s more.
At Buttercup Counseling, you get a chance to tear up the script. No more living for everyone else. No more apologizing for wanting more.
You deserve to take up space in your own life—and it’s time to do it your way.
Forget perfection.
You need honesty, courage, and a path that breaks from the pack.
Buttercup Counseling’s mission is to help you trust your instincts and reclaim your wild, essential self. We stand with people who refuse to settle for hollow wins and half-lives. You don’t need to mold yourself into someone else’s version of “enough.” You can finally put yourself first. And do it without shame.
Therapy that breaks the mold
Cookie-cutter advice has never fit. You want real change, not shallow pep talks. That’s why we skip the standard routine and hand you the tools to challenge your own limits. With personalized counseling and EMDR, we help you rewrite old stories and build a life that feels as bold as you secretly crave.
Here's how it starts.
- Schedule your free 20-minute consult
- We’ll customize a plan built for your actual life
- You start blooming into yourself
No rigid programs, no empty buzzwords. Just radical support for your unapologetic transformation.
Meet your therapist
Susan Kelley Clark, LCSW, LCAC
As the founder of Buttercup Counseling in Fishers, Indiana, Susan specializes in trauma, codependency, and relationship issues, using EMDR and other evidence-based therapies to create practical, personalized care. She works with high-performing adults who want to trust themselves and take up space in their own lives.
Susan welcomes adults of all backgrounds and identities, offering in-person and online therapy.
📚 If she weren’t a therapist: Susan would own an independent bookstore and offer Tarot readings in the back.
💜 Favorite city: New Orleans – she’d live in a little apartment with a balcony if it it weren’t for the heat and the hurricanes
🌶️ Favorite food: She could eat Indian food forever, the spicier, the better!
I see the weight you carry
You push yourself harder than anyone knows, and you’re tired of pretending you don’t feel empty. You’re not lazy or broken. You’ve learned to survive by hiding your real needs, but that’s not living.
And, I get it because I’ve lived it. Decades of clinical experience, real-life resilience, and a relentless curiosity have shaped the way I work: radically collaborative, brutally honest, and deeply invested in helping you own your story.
Here, you can admit the truth. You can want more joy, meaning, and space to breathe — and you won’t be judged for it. Your pain is real. Your dreams are real, too.
Choose Yourself. Start Today.
Keep following the same routine, or decide that you count.
Schedule your consultation now. We’ll create a plan that dares you to trust yourself and step into a life that actually belongs to you. The moment you choose yourself, everything changes.
Stop asking for permission. Claim your place. Bloom.
